Free Consultations
Available 24/7
Evidence storage area with sealed containers and chain-of-custody labels at a child advocacy center.

Sex Crimes Defense | Collin County, Texas

A Child's Accusation Is Not the End of the Story

Every review we conduct looks closely at who benefits, when the account first surfaced, and how it has changed over time.

By Heather Barbieri · Published November 20, 2026

You’ve been accused, or arrested, and you want to know whether a child’s accusation can be challenged at all. It can be. A Texas defense tests a false child sexual abuse allegation by checking its motive against the timeline, the child’s statements and the records.

This page walks through that review in plain terms. Motive is one part of it, not the whole case. It describes general Texas defense practice, so your own facts decide how it applies.

Where you are right now, and why motive matters

Motive matters because it is the reason someone might have to make a false accusation, and a defense can test it. If you’re facing a charge like this, you may fear losing your freedom, your time with your children and your name in the news. Those fears make sense.

If a charge is a first-degree felony, Texas law sets punishment at life or a term of 5 to 99 years. A fine of up to $10,000 can be added (Texas Penal Code § 12.32). That is why the review should start early.

A pending case can affect your work, your family time and your daily life. Questions come up early, so it helps to understand the review from the start. For the broader picture, read our child sex crime charges guide.

If a child's accusation has turned your life upside down, you don't have to sort through it alone. Barbieri Law Firm offers a free, confidential consultation to review it with you. Talk it through with our team — the first consultation is free, confidential, and carries no obligation.

Close-up of a fingerprinting being taken during a criminal investigation, with a handcuffed person visible in the background.

What motive means in a Texas child sex crime case

Motive is the reason a person might have for making a false accusation. In a family dispute, that can mean a custody advantage, anger over a separation, or pressure from relatives who have taken sides. A defense treats motive as a credibility question: does the accusation fit the family history and the record?

Indecency with a child, for example, involves sexual contact with a child younger than 17, done with intent to arouse or gratify sexual desire (Texas Penal Code § 21.11). Sexual contact covers touching a child’s anus, breast or genitals, including through clothing, and touching any part of a child’s body with another person’s anus, breast or genitals, in either case with that intent (Texas Penal Code § 21.11). Sexual contact under that subsection is a second-degree felony. Certain exposure conduct is a third-degree felony.

A defense does not guess at motive. It ties each possible reason to dates and documents, so the reason can be checked.

Motive alone does not decide a case. A strong reason to lie does not prove the child lied. A weak reason does not prove the child told the truth. The defense tests the reason and the evidence side by side.

Why accusations surface during divorce, custody or CPS proceedings

An accusation can surface during a divorce, a custody dispute or a CPS investigation, and the timing of those proceedings becomes evidence. The Texas Department of Family and Protective Services investigates child-abuse allegations, so a CPS case can run alongside a criminal case (DFPS investigations). Family court can run alongside both.

A defense builds a timeline across those tracks. It asks:

  • When did the separation or custody disagreement begin?
  • When was the accusation first made, and to whom?
  • Who was present at each key event?
  • What was already pending in family court or with CPS?

Dates matter most when they line up with a filing, a hearing or a report to CPS. Each date gets checked against records such as court filings, text messages and CPS notes. The timeline is not assumed; it is tested. If the accusation came after a filing, the defense examines that fact. The fact alone does not show the accusation is false.

Testing the child’s accounts for consistency

A defense compares every statement the child has given, in the order they were made, to see whether the details change. It also compares what the child told an interviewer with what the child told family members. Each comparison shows whether the story stayed the same.

The review starts with the record. Article 39.15 limits discovery under Texas Code of Criminal Procedure art. 39.14: a court shall allow discovery of certain child pornography and abuse material, but must deny a defense request to copy it if the state makes it reasonably available to you for inspection. Those can include recorded forensic interviews. A forensic interview is a recorded interview with a child, used in abuse investigations.

A defense looks for changes in details over time, new details that appear after certain conversations, and differences between early and later accounts. It also reviews how each interview was done: the questions asked, whether the interviewer suggested answers, and whether the recording is complete.

Texas evidence rules govern how inconsistencies reach a jury. Before asking a witness about an earlier statement, a lawyer must follow the Texas evidence rules on prior statements. Under the Texas evidence rule on a witness’s earlier inconsistent statement, the witness must be allowed to explain or deny it, and outside proof of that statement is admissible only if the witness is first questioned about it and does not unequivocally admit making it; none of the requirements in that subdivision apply to an opposing party’s statement under Rule 801(e)(2) (Texas Rules of Evidence). In these cases, Article 38.072 provides one hearsay route: a statement describing the alleged offense, made by the child to the first person 18 years of age or older, other than the defendant, to whom the child spoke about the offense, is not inadmissible because of the hearsay rule if, on or before the 14th day before the date the proceeding begins, the party intending to offer it notifies the adverse party of that intention, provides the name of the witness through whom it will be offered, and provides a written summary of the statement; the trial court finds, in a hearing conducted outside the presence of the jury, that the statement is reliable based on its time, content and circumstances; and the child testifies or is available to testify at the proceeding (Texas Code of Criminal Procedure art. 38.072).

Who had access to the child and who may have shaped the story

A defense asks who spent time with the child, who talked with the child about the allegation, and when those conversations happened. Adults close to the family can have a stake in a custody dispute. The defense asks about that stake openly and without assumptions.

Messages, call logs, social media posts and conversations between adults can show when the subject first came up. The defense reviews those records for timing and sequence. Each adult involved gets the same questions, and no one is assumed to have acted improperly.

Texas also treats some false reports as a crime. A person commits an offense if, with intent to deceive, the person knowingly makes a false report under the child-protection chapter (Texas Family Code § 261.107). The offense is a state jail felony unless the person has a prior conviction under that section. The statute requires intent to deceive, so it does not reach every report that turns out to be wrong.

Subsection (b) of the same statute lets a court restrict a reporter’s access to the child. That can follow a finding in a parent-child suit that the report was false or lacked factual foundation.

Evidence that can confirm or challenge the accusation

The evidence is tested against the specific claims: dates, places and the order of events. Relevant evidence often includes charging documents, forensic interview recordings, medical records, digital evidence, phone and location records, and witness statements. Medical records can help or hurt either side, depending on what they show. A defense reads them closely rather than assuming a result.

Digital evidence has limits. Police generally need a warrant before searching a cell phone, even one seized during an arrest (Riley v. California). Under Riley v. California, police generally need a warrant before searching the information on a cell phone, even when the phone was seized incident to arrest (Riley v. California, 573 U.S. 373, 401 (2014)). For historical cell-site location records held by a phone company, the government generally must get a warrant supported by probable cause (Carpenter v. United States).

Certain child sexual material is handled differently. A court must deny a defendant’s request to copy it when the state makes it reasonably available for inspection (Texas Code of Criminal Procedure art. 39.15). That means review happens at a state facility, not on a copy you keep.

In an online sting, the messages are central evidence. Article 39.15 governs discovery of certain child material and does not address entrapment; entrapment is a defense under a different statute, Texas Penal Code § 8.06, when a law enforcement agent induces the conduct with persuasion or other means likely to cause someone to offend. Merely affording an opportunity is not entrapment (Texas Penal Code § 8.06). The offense rests on the solicitation, not on whether a meeting occurred.

Not sure what your next step is?

Talk it through with our team — the first consultation is free, confidential, and carries no obligation.

Protecting your position in the first days after an accusation

Keep what you already have, and contact Barbieri Law Firm before you discuss the accusation with investigators or caseworkers.

Keep every message, record and document connected to the accusation. Don’t delete anything. Avoid contact with the child or the accuser about the allegation. Those conversations can be misread later, so talk through them with a lawyer first. Write down what you remember, with dates, and share those notes with your lawyer.

Be careful with statements. Under Miranda, whether a statement made during custodial interrogation can be used depends on whether police first gave four warnings. Those include the right to remain silent and the right to a lawyer (Dickerson v. United States). Ask a lawyer how those rights apply to your situation.

CPS, family court and the criminal case can move on separate tracks. A statement in one setting may affect the others. For a related read, see our guide for family members of the accused.

A handcuffed person in an orange jumpsuit sits at a table during an interrogation.

Talk with Barbieri Law Firm about the accusation against you

You can talk with Barbieri Law Firm about the accusation against you before you decide anything else.

If you’re facing an accusation tied to a family dispute, a CPS case or a sting, it can feel urgent. You don’t have to settle every question at once. Bring the timeline, the charging papers and any messages or records you have. We will review the evidence, including the child’s statements and the timeline, and explain your options. A first conversation can also help you see which records matter most.

Frequently asked questions

Can a child’s accusation be false in a Texas custody case?

Yes, an accusation can be false. Texas makes a knowingly false report, made with intent to deceive, a crime.

Can a child’s statement to an adult be used in court?

Under Article 38.072 of the Texas Code of Criminal Procedure, one route for admitting a child’s hearsay statement requires advance notice, a reliability finding by the judge, and the child’s availability to testify; the article applies only to listed offenses against a child under 18 or a person with a disability.

Does an online solicitation charge require that a meeting happened?

No. Under Texas law, it is not a defense that the meeting did not occur.

The initial consultation is free, confidential, and carries no obligation to continue. No lawyer can ensure an outcome, but the meeting gives you a chance to review the facts and your options. Call (972) 424-1902 or send your case details.

Attorney responsible for this site: Heather Barbieri, Barbieri Law Firm, Frisco, Texas.

Barbieri Law Firm, 17 Cowboys Way, Suite 175, Frisco, TX 75034. The information you obtain at this site is not, nor is it intended to be, legal advice. You should consult an attorney for advice regarding your individual situation. Contacting us does not create an attorney-client relationship. Results listed are not a guarantee or indication of future case results.

Questions a defense review can examine

Timing of the report

When the accusation was first made, and what was happening in the child's life and the family at that time, can shed light on how the account developed.

Consistency across retellings

We compare what the child said to different people, in different settings, to see where the details hold steady and where they shift.

Outside influence

Conversations with parents, relatives, school staff or others can shape what a child remembers. We look at who said what, and when.

Custody and family disputes

Divorce, custody or property disagreements can give a person a reason to make a report. We examine that context carefully.

How we approach a review

Reviewing the records

We obtain and study police reports, forensic interview recordings, school and medical records, and messages, so every claim is tested against the evidence.

Identifying motive

We look at what the accuser may have gained or feared, and whether those pressures existed at the time of the report.

Explaining your options

We walk you through what the evidence shows, where its weak points are, and the choices available to you.

Be careful before you speak about the accusation

Statements made to family, friends, school staff, investigators or on social media can later be used in your case. Speak with a lawyer before you respond to any accusation.

Your first consultation is free, confidential and carries no obligation to continue.

Request a Consultation

Fill out the short form and we will take it from there.

Call Now — Free Consultation (972) 424-1902