Free Consultations
Available 24/7
Interior of a police evidence room with labeled storage shelves and documentation systems for investigations.

Sex Crimes Defense | Collin County and Dallas-Fort Worth

Charged With Child Sexual Assault, but the State Has No Physical Evidence?

A case can be built on statements, interviews, records and other proof. Our Frisco team reviews every part of the State's case and explains your options. Free initial consultation, confidential and without obligation to continue.

By Heather Barbieri · Published November 4, 2026

Yes. The child offense is built from conduct and the child’s age, not from a lab result. This page explains what that means for a family member and what a defense review examines.

Short Answer: Yes, a Texas Child Sexual Assault Charge Can Proceed Without Physical Evidence

Physical evidence is not an element of the offense. Under Texas Penal Code § 22.011, a person commits the child offense when the person intentionally or knowingly causes penetration of a child’s anus or sexual organ by any means. The statute also covers other listed contact and penetration acts involving a child. It applies regardless of whether the person knows the child’s age.

The fact finder is the jury, or the judge when there is no jury.

A defense review starts with three questions. What must the State prove? What does it actually have? Where are the gaps and conflicts? The answers shape every decision that follows.

A hand rests on a desk beside a stack of investigative documents and newspaper clippings.

How These Cases Usually Start

A case can begin with a report to police, to a child protective investigator, or to both. Each route leads to interviews, and those interviews often become the center of the file. A child may give more than one account over time, and each account goes into the record.

When there are no medical or forensic findings, the case turns on words, timing and surrounding facts. Texas publishes Texas sexual-assault evidence procedures for identifying, collecting and preserving physical evidence from patients. A review asks whether any such evidence was collected, and what it showed.

Timing is a fact a review checks closely. That includes when the report was made, how much time passed, and the dates the child gave for each event.

Family members should know one more thing early. The Texas crime victim rights page describes those protections. Knowing them helps a family read the process clearly.

Burden of Proof: What the State Must Still Show

Each criminal case turns on the specific charge and the evidence offered for it, and a lawyer can explain how those details apply to a particular situation.

That rule shapes how a case without physical proof is judged. The fact finder weighs the testimony and records it actually hears. If the case rests on one account, the details, consistency and context of that account matter. Where corroborating proof is missing, the defense can point that out.

A defense review does not assume the account is false, and it does not assume it is true. It tests the account against the rest of the file.

Two evidence rules also matter.

A criminal case and a CPS investigation are separate matters with separate rules. Keep them apart when you read any notice or letter. It is not a prediction of how any case will end.

What a Defense Review Covers

A defense review reads the full file, from the first statement to the last record. It checks:

  • The charge and its elements. The age, conduct and relationship facts the State must establish.
  • Every statement. Each account the child has given, in order, including how it changed over time.
  • Interview materials. Recordings and interview notes, including the questions asked and any leading language.
  • Medical and exam records. What they show, and what they do not show.
  • Timeline and access. Locations, witness accounts, and school, family or digital records that bear on dates and contact.
  • Missing steps. Leads never tested, recordings never made, and records never requested.

Statutory defenses are part of the review too. Texas Penal Code § 22.011 includes a defense in subsection (d) for medical care given to a child, but only for the child offense in subsection (a)(2), and only if the conduct did not include any contact between the anus or sexual organ of the child and the mouth, anus, or sexual organ of the actor or a third party. It also includes an affirmative defense in subsection (e) that depends on the ages involved and other conditions. A review checks whether either one fits the facts.

Finally, the review explains the findings in plain language. Your family should understand the case before any decision is made.

How the Review Works, Step by Step

The review runs in five steps. Each stage moves at the pace of the court’s schedule and the discovery the State produces.

  1. Consultation. The first consultation is free, confidential, and carries no obligation to continue. Your family describes the charge and the timeline.
  2. Gather the file. Charging papers, bond conditions, and whatever discovery the State has produced so far.
  3. Review. The firm’s lawyers read the file and write a list of open questions.
  4. Explanation. You get a plain-language account of the State’s likely theory, the weak points, and the options.
  5. Decisions. Choices are made with the family after consultation. The case then moves through its next stages as they arise.

Some families expect a decision at the first meeting. Decisions follow the review, not the other way around.

Defenses and Options Discussed After the Review

Defense options come out of the review. They are discussed with the family, not promised in advance.

  • Challenge to the elements. Whether the State can prove the age, conduct and relationship it alleges.
  • Credibility and consistency. Changes in an account, and whether interview methods were suggestive.
  • Investigation gaps. Untested leads, missing recordings, and records never obtained.
  • Negotiation. Discussion of a lesser offense, if the facts support one.
  • Whether any limit applies depends on the exact charge and the facts. Texas Penal Code § 12.04 classifies felonies according to the relative seriousness of the offense into five categories. Under art. 12.05, time the accused is absent from the state is not counted.

No lawyer can ensure an outcome. Options are weighed with your family once the facts are known.

Why Barbieri Law Firm

Barbieri Law Firm is an all-women criminal defense firm based in Frisco, Texas. The firm defends people accused of sex crimes and assaultive offenses across Collin County, Dallas-Fort Worth and Texas. That includes child sex crimes and aggravated sexual assault.

Our lawyers are Heather Barbieri and Carrie Thomas. Support staff assist them with the firm’s daily work.

Heather Jean Barbieri, Board Certified, Criminal Law — Texas Board of Legal Specialization.

Our approach is to read the full file, explain the options in plain language, and answer your questions before any decision is made.

Police officers reviewing evidence and taking notes during a criminal investigation.

Common Questions and Next Step

Can a child sexual assault charge proceed with no physical evidence in Texas?

Yes. The child offense does not list physical evidence as an element, so a case can rest on other proof.

What should the family bring to the first consultation?

Bring the charging papers, any bond paperwork, letters, and a list of key dates.

Questions a family may have about speaking with police or CPS

Talking with a lawyer can help a family understand its options before anyone answers more questions. Each statement can shape the case.

What is the penalty for aggravated sexual assault of a child in Texas?

Under Texas Penal Code § 22.021(f), the minimum term rises to 25 years if the victim is younger than 10, or younger than 14 when the offense is committed in a manner described by (a)(2)(A).

Your loved one may be facing a charge built on statements, with nothing physical for anyone to examine. You don’t have to sort through that alone. Schedule a consultation, call (972) 424-1902, or send us your case details.

Attorney responsible for this site: Heather Barbieri, Barbieri Law Firm, Frisco, Texas.

Barbieri Law Firm, 17 Cowboys Way, Suite 175, Frisco, TX 75034. The information you obtain at this site is not, nor is it intended to be, legal advice. You should consult an attorney for advice regarding your individual situation. Contacting us does not create an attorney-client relationship. Results listed are not a guarantee or indication of future case results.

How we approach a case built on other proof

We review the full file

We go through the charging papers, interview recordings, reports and any records the State relies on, so nothing is overlooked.

We test the State's proof

We examine what each piece of the case actually shows and where it is incomplete, inconsistent or open to question.

We explain your options

We walk you through the options available in your case and what each would involve, in plain language.

We keep your family informed

We answer your questions at every stage and keep you updated on what happens next.

Before you speak about the allegations

Do not discuss the allegations with investigators, family members, friends or on social media until you have spoken with a lawyer. Early choices can shape how your case moves forward.

Common questions families ask

What if there is no physical evidence?

Cases are often built on many kinds of proof, including statements, recorded interviews and messages. We review each piece with you and explain how it fits together.

What should I bring to the consultation?

Bring any charging papers, bond paperwork, letters you have received and a written list of key dates in order. Our team will tell you what else would help.

Who leads the defense?

Heather Jean Barbieri, Board Certified, Criminal Law — Texas Board of Legal Specialization. Barbieri Law Firm is an all-women firm in Frisco, Texas, serving Collin County, Dallas-Fort Worth and Texas.

How do I start?

Call (972) 424-1902 or send us your case details. Your first consultation is free, confidential and carries no obligation to continue.

Related practice areas

Request a Consultation

Fill out the short form and we will take it from there.

Call Now — Free Consultation (972) 424-1902